Jeg vil lige høre jeres mening om denne erfaring jeg har gjort mig, om det har været et tilfælde eller om det kan bruges:
Hvis jeg er i tvivl om rammene laver fejl, har jeg lavet et dokument med notesblok og herefter skriver noget tilfældig tekst, som jeg så kopierer flere gange indtil rammene er maxet ud. Havde på et tidspunkt nogle ustabile ram som crashede denne test. De fejlede også i memtest. Den her test er bare utroligt hurtigt at lave.
Tænker I at det er en egnet test til screening af rammene, så kan man altid bagefter begynde at teste blokkene enkeltvis osv?
Du kan ikke teste den del af ram som windows eller programmer bruger, så det vil altid være bedre med 2 pass Memtest, eller 10+ hvis man vil være helt sikker.
#0
udfra hvad du siger si laver du din test forkert or kommer til en forkert kunklission hvis du mener din test er paa hoejde med memtest86
Bar du vaalger at dine notepad test virker og verifier med memtest86 viser du blot at memtest86 er lige eller bedre end din test. Du viser IKKE at din noteblok teste er paa hoejde med metest86.
Med andre ord din test viser ikke styrken af dit program da du ikke har nogle resutalter for falske negativer. Din test kan have misset fejl som metest86 ville have vist, men fordi du kun eftertester nar din notepad test viser noget. saa finder du aldrig disse svage punkter i din notpad metode.
Derudover er der masser af ramtest der virker i windows of forskellige test har forskellige styrker
memtest86 er umiddelbart den indtil vidre objetivt teste bedte ram test for boot up
prime95 er den bedste for koersel inden for windows ( men den er svaer at isolere mellem cpu og ram med)
jeg henviser til min gamle ram test software test ( copy paste til notepad)
3770K 4.4GHz 32GB
2x Kingston KHX2400C11D3/8GX
2x Kingston KHX1866C10D3/8G
2133MHz Dual channel
11-13-13-30 10-12-12-28 10-11-11-28 10-11-11-26 10-11-11-25 10-11-11-24 9-11-11-28 9-11-11-26 9-11-11-24
CMD2T V1.65 CMD1T V1.65 CMD1T V1.65 CMD1T V1.65 CMD1T V1.65 CMD1T V1.65 CMD1T V1.65 CMD1T V1.65 CMD1T V1.65
Memtest86 V7.03 OK 6:48 OK 12:50 D 0:13 D 0:01 C 0:05 C 0:00 C 0:00 C 0:00
Memtest86 V4.37 OK 4:07 OK 4:15 OK 4:30 D 0:38 D 0:05 D 0:00 D 0:00 D 0:00
Memtest86+ V5.01 OK 11:30 OK 4:50 OK 4:42 D 0:04 D 0:05 D 0:01 D 0:00 D 0:00
Prime95 V28.10 Blend OK 4:03 OK 4:01 D 0:34 D 0:00 N/B N/B N/B N/B
Intel XTU OK 4:05 OK 4:05 OK 4:05 C 0:04 N/B N/B N/B N/B
HCI Memtest OK 4:10 OK 9:07 D 0:05 D 0:00 N/B N/B N/B N/B
7-zip V16.04 Benchmark OK 8:55 OK 4:23 OK 10:04 D 0:03 N/B N/B N/B N/B
Windows Standard OK 4:00 OK 10:00 OK 4:00 OK 10:00 D 0:05 OK 13:10 OK 7:48 D 0:00
Windows Extended OK 5:33 OK 11:07 OK 10:30 OK 10:14 D 0:05 OK 9:05 OK 4:33 D 0:00
AleGr Memtest OK 4:00 OK 12:07 D 0:18 D 0:00 N/B N/B N/B N/B
RightMark Memtest OK 6:05 OK 8:16 OK 4:11 D 0:32 N/B N/B N/B N/B
Goldmemory OK 6:09 OK 9:55 OK 4:55 D 0:20 D 0:00 OK 6:35 OK 4:05 D 0:00
TechPowerUP OK 4:00 OK 4:00 D 0:11 D 0:00
11-13-13-30 11-13-13-30 11-13-13-30 11-13-13-30
CMD1T V1.6 CMD1T V1.55 CMD1T V1.50 CMD1T V1.45
Memtest86 V7.03 OK 7:20 OK 9:28 D 2:26 D 1:22
Memtest86 V4.37 OK 15:22 OK 4:09 OK 4:06 OK 9:51
Memtest86+ V5.01 OK 10:51 OK 11:28 OK 7:56 OK 5:28
Prime95 V28.10 Blend D 7:53 D 0:36 D 0:27 D 0:05
Intel XTU OK 4:05 OK 10:49 OK 14:26 OK 5:30
HCI Memtest OK 5:03 D 0:27 D 0:08 D 0:05
7-zip V16.04 Benchmark OK 5:51 OK 4:00 OK 4:05 OK 4:57
Windows Standard OK 5:12 OK 10:04 OK 17:00 OK 7:21
Windows Extended OK 7:24 OK 7:12 OK 11:30 OK 6:46
AleGr Memtest OK 11:09 OK 8:34 OK 11:17 OK 8:45
RightMark Memtest OK 8:24 OK 6:55 OK 6:52 OK 4:55
Goldmemory OK 7:05 OK 11:36 OK 10:03 OK 10:05
TechPowerUP OK 4:00 OK 4:00 OK 4:00 OK 6:00
2600K 4.5GHz 16GB
2x Crucial BLT4G3D1608DT1TX0
2x Crucial BLT4G3D1608DT1TX0
1600MHz dual Channel
9-9-9-24 8-8-8-24 7-8-8-24 7-7-7-24 7-7-7-22 7-7-7-20 7-7-7-18 7-7-7-16 7-7-6-24 7-7-6-22
CMD2T 1.5V CMD1T V1.5 CMD1T V1.5 CMD1T V1.5 CMD1T V1.5 CMD1T V1.5 CMD1T V1.5 CMD1T V1.5 CMD1T V1.5 CMD1T V1.5
Memtest86 V7.03 OK 4:16 OK 4:54* OK 8:21* OK 21:17 D 0:40 OK 4:01* OK 23:42 D 0:00 D 0:00
Memtest86 V4.37 OK 4:05 OK 10:05 OK 6:00 OK 7:38 OK 5:49 OK 17:57 OK 9:13 D 0:17 D 0:10
Memtest86+ V5.01 OK 4:07 OK 7:29 OK 5:01 OK 20:00 OK 12:30 OK 9:16 OK 6:10 D 0:00 D 0:25
Prime95 V28.10 Blend C 6:43 OK 4:15 C 0:38 C 0:44 C 0:48 C 0:42 C 0:06 C 0:59 D 7:02
Intel XTU OK 4:05 OK 4:05 OK 4:05 OK 4:05 OK 4:05 OK 4:05 C 1:44 OK 17:33 OK 13:40
HCI Memtest OK 4:15 OK 13:04 OK 4:35 OK 8:44 OK 16:47 OK 24:43 OK 9:07 D 0:00 D 0:00
7-zip V16.04 Benchmark OK 11:56 OK 9:58 OK 23:58 OK 6:03 OK 6:01 OK 4:43 OK 4:43 D 2:46 D 5:05
Windows Standards OK 9:56 OK 12:05 OK 6:00 OK 23:04 OK 10:07 OK 13:01 OK 20:03 OK 9:23 D 0:01
Windows Extended OK 24:00 OK 20:32 OK 10:15 OK 7:20 OK 23:51 OK 11:27 OK 10:54 OK 8:00 D 0:03
9-9-9-24 9-9-9-24 9-9-9-24 9-9-9-24 9-9-9-24 9-9-9-24
CMD?T V1.45 CMD?T V1.4 CMD2T V1.35 CMD2T V1.3 CMD1T V1.3 CMD1T V1.3
Memtest86 V7.03 OK 15:33 OK 4:03 OK 4:19 OK 27:09 OK 16:59
Memtest86 V4.3.7 OK 10:21 OK 6:25 OK 25:20 OK 22:27 OK 7:24
Memtest86+ V5.01 OK 24:44 OK 9:59 OK 18:47 OK 14:48 OK 20:55 OK 8:38
Prime95 V28.10 Blend OK 18:18 OK121:33
Intel XTU OK 11:23 OK 11:36 OK 23:48 OK 22:00 OK 20:55 OK 4:00
HCI Memtest OK 14:07 OK 6:46 OK 13:59 OK 5:24 OK 28:21 OK 23:22
7-zip V16.04 Benchmark OK 22:25 OK 15:03 OK 4:21 OK 6:50 OK 11:16 OK 12:41
Windows Standard OK 12:25 OK 14:04 OK 9:04 OK 5:11 OK 23:14 OK 18:07
Windows Extended OK 9:59 OK 11:15 OK 8:15 ok 24:48 OK 22:13
Standby Prevention
HCI memtest NO
Prime95 NO
Legend:
OK Passed
D Error Detected
C System Crashed
N/B Not Bootable
*note might have row hammer issues
ser ud til at hwt fjerner tabs so har er det med space i stedet so bedre at kopiere ind ti notepad
3770K 4.4GHz 32GB
2x Kingston KHX2400C11D3/8GX
2x Kingston KHX1866C10D3/8G
2133MHz Dual channel
11-13-13-30 10-12-12-28 10-11-11-28 10-11-11-26 10-11-11-25 10-11-11-24 9-11-11-28 9-11-11-26 9-11-11-24
CMD2T V1.65 CMD1T V1.65 CMD1T V1.65 CMD1T V1.65 CMD1T V1.65 CMD1T V1.65 CMD1T V1.65 CMD1T V1.65 CMD1T V1.65
Memtest86 V7.03 OK 6:48 OK 12:50 D 0:13 D 0:01 C 0:05 C 0:00 C 0:00 C 0:00
Memtest86 V4.37 OK 4:07 OK 4:15 OK 4:30 D 0:38 D 0:05 D 0:00 D 0:00 D 0:00
Memtest86+ V5.01 OK 11:30 OK 4:50 OK 4:42 D 0:04 D 0:05 D 0:01 D 0:00 D 0:00
Prime95 V28.10 Blend OK 4:03 OK 4:01 D 0:34 D 0:00 N/B N/B N/B N/B
Intel XTU OK 4:05 OK 4:05 OK 4:05 C 0:04 N/B N/B N/B N/B
HCI Memtest OK 4:10 OK 9:07 D 0:05 D 0:00 N/B N/B N/B N/B
7-zip V16.04 Benchmark OK 8:55 OK 4:23 OK 10:04 D 0:03 N/B N/B N/B N/B
Windows Standard OK 4:00 OK 10:00 OK 4:00 OK 10:00 D 0:05 OK 13:10 OK 7:48 D 0:00
Windows Extended OK 5:33 OK 11:07 OK 10:30 OK 10:14 D 0:05 OK 9:05 OK 4:33 D 0:00
AleGr Memtest OK 4:00 OK 12:07 D 0:18 D 0:00 N/B N/B N/B N/B
RightMark Memtest OK 6:05 OK 8:16 OK 4:11 D 0:32 N/B N/B N/B N/B
Goldmemory OK 6:09 OK 9:55 OK 4:55 D 0:20 D 0:00 OK 6:35 OK 4:05 D 0:00
TechPowerUP OK 4:00 OK 4:00 D 0:11 D 0:00
11-13-13-30 11-13-13-30 11-13-13-30 11-13-13-30
CMD1T V1.6 CMD1T V1.55 CMD1T V1.50 CMD1T V1.45
Memtest86 V7.03 OK 7:20 OK 9:28 D 2:26 D 1:22
Memtest86 V4.37 OK 15:22 OK 4:09 OK 4:06 OK 9:51
Memtest86+ V5.01 OK 10:51 OK 11:28 OK 7:56 OK 5:28
Prime95 V28.10 Blend D 7:53 D 0:36 D 0:27 D 0:05
Intel XTU OK 4:05 OK 10:49 OK 14:26 OK 5:30
HCI Memtest OK 5:03 D 0:27 D 0:08 D 0:05
7-zip V16.04 Benchmark OK 5:51 OK 4:00 OK 4:05 OK 4:57
Windows Standard OK 5:12 OK 10:04 OK 17:00 OK 7:21
Windows Extended OK 7:24 OK 7:12 OK 11:30 OK 6:46
AleGr Memtest OK 11:09 OK 8:34 OK 11:17 OK 8:45
RightMark Memtest OK 8:24 OK 6:55 OK 6:52 OK 4:55
Goldmemory OK 7:05 OK 11:36 OK 10:03 OK 10:05
TechPowerUP OK 4:00 OK 4:00 OK 4:00 OK 6:00
2600K 4.5GHz 16GB
2x Crucial BLT4G3D1608DT1TX0
2x Crucial BLT4G3D1608DT1TX0
1600MHz dual Channel
9-9-9-24 8-8-8-24 7-8-8-24 7-7-7-24 7-7-7-22 7-7-7-20 7-7-7-18 7-7-7-16 7-7-6-24 7-7-6-22
CMD2T 1.5V CMD1T V1.5 CMD1T V1.5 CMD1T V1.5 CMD1T V1.5 CMD1T V1.5 CMD1T V1.5 CMD1T V1.5 CMD1T V1.5 CMD1T V1.5
Memtest86 V7.03 OK 4:16 OK 4:54* OK 8:21* OK 21:17 D 0:40 OK 4:01* OK 23:42 D 0:00 D 0:00
Memtest86 V4.37 OK 4:05 OK 10:05 OK 6:00 OK 7:38 OK 5:49 OK 17:57 OK 9:13 D 0:17 D 0:10
Memtest86+ V5.01 OK 4:07 OK 7:29 OK 5:01 OK 20:00 OK 12:30 OK 9:16 OK 6:10 D 0:00 D 0:25
Prime95 V28.10 Blend C 6:43 OK 4:15 C 0:38 C 0:44 C 0:48 C 0:42 C 0:06 C 0:59 D 7:02
Intel XTU OK 4:05 OK 4:05 OK 4:05 OK 4:05 OK 4:05 OK 4:05 C 1:44 OK 17:33 OK 13:40
HCI Memtest OK 4:15 OK 13:04 OK 4:35 OK 8:44 OK 16:47 OK 24:43 OK 9:07 D 0:00 D 0:00
7-zip V16.04 Benchmark OK 11:56 OK 9:58 OK 23:58 OK 6:03 OK 6:01 OK 4:43 OK 4:43 D 2:46 D 5:05
Windows Standards OK 9:56 OK 12:05 OK 6:00 OK 23:04 OK 10:07 OK 13:01 OK 20:03 OK 9:23 D 0:01
Windows Extended OK 24:00 OK 20:32 OK 10:15 OK 7:20 OK 23:51 OK 11:27 OK 10:54 OK 8:00 D 0:03
9-9-9-24 9-9-9-24 9-9-9-24 9-9-9-24 9-9-9-24 9-9-9-24
CMD?T V1.45 CMD?T V1.4 CMD2T V1.35 CMD2T V1.3 CMD1T V1.3 CMD1T V1.3
Memtest86 V7.03 OK 15:33 OK 4:03 OK 4:19 OK 27:09 OK 16:59
Memtest86 V4.3.7 OK 10:21 OK 6:25 OK 25:20 OK 22:27 OK 7:24
Memtest86+ V5.01 OK 24:44 OK 9:59 OK 18:47 OK 14:48 OK 20:55 OK 8:38
Prime95 V28.10 Blend OK 18:18 OK121:33
Intel XTU OK 11:23 OK 11:36 OK 23:48 OK 22:00 OK 20:55 OK 4:00
HCI Memtest OK 14:07 OK 6:46 OK 13:59 OK 5:24 OK 28:21 OK 23:22
7-zip V16.04 Benchmark OK 22:25 OK 15:03 OK 4:21 OK 6:50 OK 11:16 OK 12:41
Windows Standard OK 12:25 OK 14:04 OK 9:04 OK 5:11 OK 23:14 OK 18:07
Windows Extended OK 9:59 OK 11:15 OK 8:15 ok 24:48 OK 22:13
Standby Prevention
HCI memtest NO
Prime95 NO
Legend:
OK Passed
D Error Detected
C System Crashed
N/B Not Bootable
*note might have row hammer issues
Som du kan se paa 33770k system saa finder memtest86 v7.03, Prime95 v28.10blend , HCI memtest, AleGR mentest, TechpowerUP d test programmer som er bedste til at finde fejl. resten kore fint i 4 timer uden problemer og finder foerste fejl i naeste iteration med flere fejl pa rammen
I 2600K systemet viser dig sig igen at prime95 er staerkere end alle andre after fulght at memte86+ v7.03
Dette er et eksempel paa en korrekt udfoert test rsultat fra en test har ikke indflydelse paa om et andet software bliver testet eller ej
ok test metode slaaet til side
saa ser de ud ti lat din test blot er en form for fillup stress test. dvs den tester ikke efter om rammen gemmer de rigtige data. hvilket ogsaa er vigtige i en test.
det nytte ikke ret,get at du fylde din notepad op med data tog det saa er anderledes data me ndu crasher ikke pga ram fejlen ikke har ram et kode omraade
det er af samme aarsag det er dumt at teste stabilitet med Cinebench fordi den ikke tester efter om resultaterne er korrekte saa den vil misse mange fejl ( dsv du har risiko for falsk negative test).
Dog er jeg interresset som altid i at teste ting. saa link gerne til det og jeg giver det gerne en test